Club Tobacco Reviews

Member ratings from Miami Pipe Club tobacco tastings.

Club averages are calculated from member review forms. Individual reviews may include comments when provided.

Submit A Review
Order By Blend A-Z Most Reviews Top Rated Most Recent
Packaging: Tin Latest Review: May 4, 2026

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 5.00
Moisture Level 5.00
Ease of Lighting 5.00
Strength / Intensity 3.00
Smoothness 3.00
Flavor Depth 2.00
Flavor Complexity 2.00
Overall Flavor 3.00
Scent Match 3.00
Pleasantness of Smoke 3.00
Maintains Flavor 2.00
Room Note 2.00
Jed K. 3.17 / 5 · May 4, 2026

Very pleasant tin note and mildly pleasant smoke. Too bad the two don't match better.

Packaging: Bulk Majority Blend Type: Aromatic Latest Review: Oct 6, 2023

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 4.00
Moisture Level 4.00
Ease of Lighting 4.00
Strength / Intensity 3.00
Smoothness 4.00
Flavor Depth 2.00
Flavor Complexity 1.00
Overall Flavor 2.00
Scent Match 2.00
Pleasantness of Smoke 3.00
Maintains Flavor 3.00
Room Note 2.00
Ben C. 2.83 / 5 · Oct 6, 2023
Packaging: Tin Majority Blend Type: English Latest Review: Jan 5, 2026

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 3.75
Moisture Level 4.00
Ease of Lighting 4.25
Strength / Intensity 4.00
Smoothness 3.25
Flavor Depth 3.75
Flavor Complexity 3.50
Overall Flavor 3.50
Scent Match 3.50
Pleasantness of Smoke 3.25
Maintains Flavor 4.00
Room Note 3.00
Jed K. 2.42 / 5 · Jan 5, 2026

I was told it smokes like a wet dog. I agree, but better than a skunk.

James U. 4.50 / 5 · Jan 5, 2026
Rohan R. 4.00 / 5 · Jan 5, 2026
Mike W. 3.67 / 5 · Jan 5, 2026

Heavy Perique. Nice VaPer overall.

Packaging: Tin Majority Blend Type: Aromatic Latest Review: Feb 5, 2024

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 2.00
Moisture Level 3.00
Ease of Lighting 5.00
Strength / Intensity 5.00
Smoothness 4.00
Flavor Depth 3.00
Flavor Complexity 3.00
Overall Flavor 3.00
Scent Match 4.00
Pleasantness of Smoke 4.00
Maintains Flavor 4.00
Room Note 3.00
Ben C. 3.58 / 5 · Feb 5, 2024
Packaging: Tin Majority Blend Type: Aromatic Latest Review: Apr 7, 2025

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 3.25
Moisture Level 3.00
Ease of Lighting 2.00
Strength / Intensity 2.75
Smoothness 3.00
Flavor Depth 2.25
Flavor Complexity 2.25
Overall Flavor 2.50
Scent Match 2.00
Pleasantness of Smoke 2.75
Maintains Flavor 3.50
Room Note 3.00
Ben C. 3.25 / 5 · Apr 7, 2025
Unsigned 2.50 / 5 · Apr 7, 2025
Francisco P. 3.17 / 5 · Apr 7, 2025
Jed K. 1.83 / 5 · Apr 7, 2025

Flowering tin + meh smoke

Packaging: Tin Majority Blend Type: Aromatic Latest Review: Aug 5, 2024

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 3.00
Moisture Level 3.00
Ease of Lighting 2.00
Strength / Intensity 3.00
Smoothness 4.00
Flavor Depth 2.00
Flavor Complexity 2.00
Overall Flavor 2.00
Scent Match 2.00
Pleasantness of Smoke 3.00
Maintains Flavor 1.00
Room Note 2.00
Ben C. 2.42 / 5 · Aug 5, 2024
Packaging: Tin Majority Blend Type: Aromatic Latest Review: Oct 2, 2023

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 4.00
Moisture Level 3.67
Ease of Lighting 3.33
Strength / Intensity 3.67
Smoothness 3.33
Flavor Depth 3.33
Flavor Complexity 3.00
Overall Flavor 3.67
Scent Match 3.67
Pleasantness of Smoke 3.33
Maintains Flavor 3.67
Room Note 3.00
Mike N. 3.75 / 5 · Oct 2, 2023
Andres O. 2.75 / 5 · Oct 2, 2023

It's good.

Ben C. 3.92 / 5 · Oct 2, 2023
Packaging: Tin Majority Blend Type: Aromatic Latest Review: Apr 6, 2026

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 2.00
Moisture Level 1.00
Ease of Lighting 1.00
Strength / Intensity 5.00
Smoothness 3.00
Flavor Depth 3.00
Flavor Complexity 2.00
Overall Flavor 2.00
Scent Match 5.00
Pleasantness of Smoke 3.00
Maintains Flavor 3.00
Room Note 3.00
Rohan R. 2.75 / 5 · Apr 6, 2026
Packaging: Tin Majority Blend Type: Aromatic Latest Review: Aug 4, 2025

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 4.25
Moisture Level 4.25
Ease of Lighting 4.25
Strength / Intensity 3.25
Smoothness 3.50
Flavor Depth 2.00
Flavor Complexity 2.00
Overall Flavor 3.00
Scent Match 3.25
Pleasantness of Smoke 3.00
Maintains Flavor 2.75
Room Note 3.50
Unsigned 3.83 / 5 · Aug 4, 2025

The Virginias take center stage & the starfruit was scent in the tin & subtle in the smoke

Ben C. 3.33 / 5 · Aug 4, 2025
Nick P. 3.17 / 5 · Aug 4, 2025
Mike N. 2.67 / 5 · Aug 4, 2025